Sunlit apartment dining alcove with a walnut table, cream wool chairs, pale oak cabinetry and a courtyard-facing window.

Manhattan's Pied-à-Terre Tax Is Priced Off a Number Nobody Pays

The Department of Finance builds a market value figure by treating a co-op or condo as if it were a rental building. For Manhattan apartments, that figure is usually a small and uneven fraction of what the apartment would sell for.

The Rate Is Applied to a Rental Building's Value

New York's Real Property Tax Law §581 requires co-ops and condos to be assessed as though they were rental buildings. DOF matches each building to "comparable rentals" and works out a value from what those rentals earn, not from what apartments in the building sell for. For the 2026-27 and 2027-28 tax years, the surcharge uses that rental-based figure. The NYC Department of Finance says a co-op or condo with a DOF value of $1 million or more "is comparable to a single-family home valued at $5 million or more."

That gap isn't the same everywhere, and the direction it runs matters. In a June 2024 fiscal note, the NYC Comptroller compared DOF values with sales-based estimates. The median ratio was 20.6%, so DOF captured about a fifth of true market value. The ratio also fell as prices rose. At the median price per square foot, DOF's comparable rentals came to about 24% of the sales figure. In the top 10% it was about 15%, and in the top 1% about 11%. The Comptroller's most extreme example was 220 Central Park South. Units there had traded above $10,000 a square foot, while the building's FY2024 DOF value was $404 a square foot.

The same study found that more than a quarter of co-ops and condos were valued outside the range of their own comparable rentals. It also found that buildings around Central Park, which bring some of the city's highest prices, were on average not at the top of the DOF value range. These are FY2024 figures. They describe how the valuation system works, not what any particular unit carries today.

A Manhattan broker told The Real Deal on October 6 that buyers around $5 million are the most likely to "pause or to look for a lower price, or to not buy."

A Change in 2028

The low rental-based values are temporary. For fiscal years beginning on or after July 1, 2028, Tax Law §1350 moves co-ops and condos to a "phase two market value" with a $5 million threshold. DOF must base that value on comparable co-op and condo sales, which is not necessarily the unit's own sale price. Phase two is already written into the statute. DOF's July rule package says it did not need to address the phase-two valuation method in that rulemaking, so the details are still to come.

Leases and the Rental Market

In August, brokers told The Real Deal that landlords were asking tenants to certify full-time residence or provide tax documents. One downtown landlord whose rent was above $50,000 a month said the surcharge would take about four months' rent and added a full-time-residency rider to an existing lease. The same report described a part-time client turned down for a $30,000-a-month rental because the landlord wanted a full-time resident. The ownership tax is now affecting who can rent part-time as well.

The sales data from the past quarter doesn't show a clear pullback. Douglas Elliman's Q3 2026 report, with data as of October 1, showed Manhattan signed contracts down 13.0% year over year to 2,126, while the average contract price rose 3.6% to $2.13 million. Crain's New York Business reported that Manhattan had its best third quarter for sales since 2022 despite the new tax.

The Legal Calendar

The tax is in effect, but it faces two legal challenges. On September 29, Justice Wayne M. Ozzi of the Supreme Court in Richmond County ruled in O'Brien v. City of New York. He found that DOF's notices to about 17,000 homeowners were "arbitrary and capricious" and ordered the city to redo the notice process. The city appealed, and the order was stayed, so the rollout continues while the appeal is pending. The Appellate Division, Second Department's October 6 scheduling order set October 19 for the homeowners' brief and October 21 for the city's reply. A separate suit, Ross v. State of New York, challenges whether the surcharge is constitutional. Holland & Knight reported that oral arguments are scheduled for November 30.

If you're weighing a pied-à-terre purchase or preparing to sell a unit a part-time buyer might want, Jeffrey Goodman can help. Let's Connect.

Work With Jeff

Jeff combines his love of the city’s rich history and his commitment to bringing New York’s great neighborhoods to life for his clients and friends by hosting several industry award-winning programs.

Follow Me on Instagram