A quiet apartment terrace overlooks warm brick East Harlem residential buildings in soft late-autumn afternoon light.

What the Last Second Avenue Dig Tells East Harlem Buyers

In 2007, the first year of Second Avenue Subway construction on the Upper East Side, New York magazine ran a diary of the dig. By late summer, one pizzeria near East 91st Street reported revenue down 23 percent from the year before, and two neighboring storefronts had closed. At street level, those years read like a neighborhood losing ground.

Apartment prices on the same blocks were rising faster than prices in the rest of the Upper East Side. That history is the one to keep in mind in East Harlem, where the second phase of the same subway line has moved from planning into blasting.

A Walk Up the Alignment, South to North

Start with what you can see on Second Avenue this week, walking north. The MTA lists Phase 2 as under construction. It plans stations at 106th and 116th Streets on Second Avenue and a third at 125th Street and Lexington Avenue, with connections to the 4, 5 and 6 trains and Metro-North. Three major contracts have been awarded: utility relocation in January 2024, tunneling and the 125th Street excavation to Connect Plus Partners in August 2025, and the 106th Street station to Skanska-Walsh-Traylor in June 2026.

At the south end, crews have been replacing a water main between 104th and 105th Streets, and utility and restoration work runs along 105th through 111th. At the 106th Street station, piling has been under way at the 108th Street entrance, and the MTA's November 10 update scheduled piling at the 106th Street entrance to start that week, with the M106 bus stop moving east toward First Avenue.

Ten blocks north, 2240 and 2242 Second Avenue at 115th Street are scheduled to come down at the end of this month to make room for the 116th Street station. Demolition of 2302 and 2308 Second Avenue at 118th Street, the site of the station's second entrance, began the week of November 2. Since November 6, Second Avenue traffic between 119th and 120th Streets has been shifted to the west side, with three lanes open. That arrangement runs until early December.

The 120th Street yard is where the tunnel begins. Crews there are digging the shaft that will launch the tunnel boring machine. The first machine passed its factory test and is due in East Harlem early next year. In 2027 it will start boring from 120th Street toward 125th Street and continue west past Lenox Avenue.

Construction is furthest along on 125th Street. In the MTA's November 10 update to Community Board 11, the entrance shaft at Lexington had reached 79 feet of a planned 133.5. That took 39 blasts through November 6, about three a week. At the Park Avenue yard, the third test blast went off November 7, and full-scale blasting was set to begin the following week. The MTA's notice for that site expects blasting to continue through the end of 2027. It also warns that pedestrians and traffic may be stopped briefly during each blast.

The last stated date for passenger service is September 2032, from the Governor's office in its August 2025 tunneling announcement. That leaves roughly six years between this week's blasting and the first train.

What the Upper East Side Paid During Its Own Dig

The best evidence on how buyers treat a long construction period comes from Phase 1. Researchers writing for the Lincoln Institute of Land Policy in June 2020 compared sales in the Second Avenue corridor, 59th to 100th Streets between First and Third Avenues, with sales elsewhere on the Upper East Side.

Their findings cover the years when Second Avenue was hardest to live on. From 2007 through 2012, the period of heaviest construction, prices across the Upper East Side rose 10.6 percent in real terms over 2003 to 2006. Prices in the corridor rose another 8.8 percent beyond that. The authors concluded that buyers' anticipation of the train was "strong enough to outweigh the disamenity effects from construction." Buyers paid more during the noise, the fencing and the closed storefronts, not less.

Over 2013 to 2019 the corridor's lead grew to 14.8 percent over 2003 to 2006 levels. The effect was largest in 2016 through 2018, the years around the January 2017 opening, and it stopped growing by early 2019. The authors read that as the market having "largely priced in" the subway. Their main estimates of the overall premium range from 4.4 to 10.2 percent, depending on how the comparison is built. For properties within 0.3 miles of a new station, the range is 4.1 to 7.4 percent.

Opening Day Itself Moved Little

If the premium built up gradually, the opening should not show up as a sudden jump, and it didn't. In a 2018 look at Yorkville by 6sqft, Upper East Side co-op prices were $1,067 a square foot a year before the opening and $1,041 around the opening. They reached $1,203 by July 2018. Storefronts behaved much the same way. In April 2017, amNewYork found that Second Avenue businesses had seen no immediate surge in interest after the Q began running. Café Beach was planning to expand, and Annie and Company Needlepoint was picking up some new shoppers.

Investors should look at the rent findings in the Lincoln Institute paper. After 2013, asking rents in the corridor were only 1.8 percent higher than in the comparison area, and after the 2017 opening the gap was 0.69 percent. On Phase 1, the subway's value showed up far more in sale prices than in rents.

Where East Harlem Sits on That Curve

East Harlem's prices, buildings and housing mix differ from Yorkville's, so Phase 1 sets a pattern to compare against rather than a number to expect. PropertyShark's East Harlem figures for the third quarter of 2026 show a $700,000 median sale price, up 19.1 percent from the same quarter of 2025, on 45 transactions, up 32.4 percent. The median price per square foot over the same quarter was $910, up 3.7 percent. Over that year, the price of a square foot rose far more slowly than the median sale price, so a headline median says less about block-by-block value than the per-foot figure does.

For a sense of budgets across the area, the Brown Harris Stevens third-quarter 2026 Manhattan report puts Upper Manhattan resale medians at $450,000 for a one-bedroom, $765,000 for a two-bedroom and $1.04 million for three bedrooms or more.

The development pipeline already assumes the line is coming. Announcing the start of public review in May 2025, the Mayor's Office described a proposed 38-story building with about 680 homes directly above the future 125th Street station. MTA Chair Janno Lieber said there that the extension would make the area "even more attractive." Directly southeast of that site, 180 East 125th Street, a 711-unit rental tower with a planned supermarket, had passed its halfway mark by September, New York YIMBY reported. The 2319 Third Avenue phase of the same development plans more than 400 affordable rentals and about 80 affordable ownership homes, according to 6sqft, with a start slated for late 2026 or early 2027. On Second Avenue between 125th and 126th Streets, the city's request for proposals for about 140 mixed-income homes says outright that the project complements the subway extension, 6sqft reported in July.

All of these are plans or buildings still under construction. They add up to thousands of new homes around the terminal station, so a buyer near 125th Street will be buying into more neighbors and more competing listings, along with the train.

Reading a Listing on the Alignment

If Phase 1 is any guide, the construction years are not a discount you can wait out. They are the years when the premium builds. The practical questions are about the specific block. A one-bedroom near the Park Avenue yard will live with blasting through 2027. An apartment near 106th Street is at the start of its station work. A building on the side streets around 120th will sit near the tunnel launch site when boring begins next year. Ask which of those applies before you compare prices per square foot across East Harlem.

The street itself is part of the price. The MTA's November update counted 71 businesses affected by construction fencing and traffic setups. The agency's sign program, including "Open for Business" banners, began after the community raised concerns about visibility and foot traffic. The MTA's storefront chart for 2024 to 2026 shows vacancy of 15 to 20 percent on Second Avenue, First Avenue and 125th Street, against 10 to 15 percent on 116th Street. The project also needs property for entrances, ventilation buildings and the boring machine launch, and the MTA lists those acquisitions as underway. If you are deciding on a building close to the work, read the MTA's posted notices for that corner along with the listing.

For buyers also weighing Central Harlem's co-ops and townhouses, my earlier guide to choosing between Harlem co-ops, condos and townhouses covers building types. For newer condos, the tax abatement schedule inside Harlem listings runs alongside the subway timeline.

A Few Questions Buyers Ask

When is the train supposed to run? The last stated target is September 2032, from the state's August 2025 announcement. The milestones closer at hand are the boring machine's arrival in early 2027 and blasting at Park Avenue through the end of 2027.

Does the Upper East Side result tell me how much East Harlem will rise? No. It shows when buyers on a similar project paid up: mostly during construction and in the years around the opening, with gains leveling off about two years after the first train. The size of any East Harlem premium will depend on East Harlem.

Should an investor expect rents to follow sale prices? On Phase 1 they did not. Corridor asking rents ended up less than 1 percent above the comparison area after the 2017 opening, while sale prices gained far more.

If you are looking at an apartment between 106th and 125th Streets and want to know how its block fits the construction schedule, or what the current pace of blasting means for its price, Jeffrey Goodman is glad to walk that stretch of Second Avenue with you and go through it building by building. Let's Connect.

Work With Jeff

Jeff combines his love of the city’s rich history and his commitment to bringing New York’s great neighborhoods to life for his clients and friends by hosting several industry award-winning programs.

Follow Me on Instagram